Powered By InformationWeek Business Technology Network
 
Welcome Guest. | Log In| Register | Membership Benefits
  • Email this page E-mail this page
  • |  Print Print this page
  • |   Bookmark and Share

From Security Perspective, Windows 7 Off To A Rocky Start

Experts express consternation over early vulnerabilities, UAC configuration issues

Oct 22, 2009 | 05:02 PM

By Tim Wilson
DarkReading

The global launch of Microsoft's next-generation Windows 7 operating system today was greeted with fanfare -- and some grumbling from security professionals who worry the new OS already has too many holes.

Windows 7, which has been broadly beta-tested for many months, is hailed as being easier to use than its predecessor, Vista, which didn't catch on the way many industry watchers had expected. But if the new environment is easier on the user, then it isn't as secure as it could be, security professionals say.

First, there is the issue of vulnerabilities. Microsoft has patched several security flaws in Windows 7 since last November, and a zero-day exploit of vulnerabilities in Microsoft's Server Message Block (SMB) technology affected both new and old versions of Windows last month. The SMB vulnerabilities were patched in the most recent round of upgrades last week.

Even as Microsoft fixed the SMB problem, it revealed on Patch Tuesday that another vulnerability, a flaw in Windows CryptoAPI, could allow spoofing. That vulnerability was rated "important" in the most recent round of patches.

"[Windows 7] has a great look and feel and is overall much smoother than Windows Vista, while at the same time improving on its security measures," says Wolfgang Kandek, CTO of security vendor Qualys. "However...consumers should hit the 'Update' button once it is installed. Software security is such a dynamic space -- with monthly updates, in the short time that it takes to get a product finished, packaged, and delivered, multiple security [advisories] have been produced. For example, Windows 7 was affected by five of the 13 security advisories that Microsoft published in October's Patch Tuesday."

While most security experts were not surprised by the vulnerabilities that have already turned up in Windows 7, some continue to complain that the implementation of Microsoft's User Access Control feature in the new OS could create even more security problems than were seen in Vista.

In a nutshell, experts say, Windows 7 makes it easier for users to turn off or ratchet down the capabilities of UAC to make the new OS easier to use. Unlike Vista, which required a special utility to change UAC settings, Windows 7 enables administrators to simply turn off or reduce security prompts that are designed to warn users they are about to do something risky.

In fact, the default configuration of Windows 7 continues to give users administrative privileges and doesn't set the UAC controls on maximum. As a result, IT administrators will have to change settings on Windows 7 PCs if they want to get the full benefit of UAC -- or if they want users to run the so-called "standard" configuration, in which the end user doesn't not have admin privileges.

"It's kind of a time bomb," says Eric Voskuil, CTO at BeyondTrust, which makes tools that help enterprises manage user privileges. "In the default configuration, the UAC slider is in the second position, which is insecure. There's a reason you don't want to turn off those prompts, but Windows 7 actually makes that easier."

By simplifying the user's ability to change UAC controls, Microsoft might also have made it easier for hackers to distribute malware to Windows 7 PCs, experts say.

"Increasing operating system usability also increases security risks -- risks of infection and compromise of data and functionality," says Ray Dickenson, CTO of Authentium, another security tool vendor. "The changes to Windows 7 UAC have made it easy for malware writers to turn UAC off entirely -- without the user's knowledge."

Long Zheng, a security researcher, published a proof-of-concept back in June that exploits the UAC flaw. Microsoft says it doesn't consider the UAC settings to be a vulnerability, and the company has stated it has no intent to change the UAC feature.

Have a comment on this story? Please click "Discuss" below. If you'd like to contact Dark Reading's editors directly, send us a message.


Subscribe to RSS



Vulnerability Management Reports

report Compliance 101: Creating a Strong Vulnerability Management Strategy
Assessing new threats is only the first step in finding and shoring up weak spots in your defenses. Most infosec groups must also factor in a broader audit of compliance with regulatory standards such as HIPAA and PCI. In this Dark Reading Tech Center report, we outline best practices for compliance-oriented vulnerability management; discuss helpful technologies; and address the process of mapping compliance requirements to vulnerability detection and remediation.

report Ground Zero: Building a Layered Defense Against Unknown Threats
The moment a malicious hacker or digital criminal exploits an unreported, unpatched flaw, the countdown to chaos begins. Here's how to employ a defense in depth strategy to make it through those critical first days relatively unscathed. The process isn't painless, but there are some key steps that may help you speed the effort to get your infrastructure back to normal.

report Assessing the Danger: How IT Can Ace Vulnerability Management
Finding the flaws in your operating systems and applications is only the beginning. You then need to plot a path to security and ensure that no new weaknesses find their way onto your network. In this Dark Reading Analytics report, we offer some step-by-step recommendations on how to do that. First up: an overview of the problem.

Related Content

Vulnerability Management Buyer's Checklist
Get this 12-point Checklist of key considerations every IT security professional needs to be aware of before choosing a vulnerability management solution.

Case Study: eBay, Inc. - Securing the World's Online Marketplace
Learn how eBay was able to automate their network security auditing and get meaningful, actionable reports.

7 Essential Steps to Achieve, Measure and Prove Optimal Security
Whether you're protecting 5 servers or 5,000, this paper details the essential aspects of putting into place a measurable and sustainable vulnerability management program.

Free Trial - Vulnerability Management
Free 14-day trial of award-winning vulnerability management solution from Qualys. Identify, fix, and report on network security threats. Try Now.