The Fine Line of Feedback: 6 Tips for Talking to Security Pros

Feedback is a two-way street in terms of giving, receiving, and knowing how to give and receive.

Joshua Goldfarb, Field CISO

May 8, 2019

4 Min Read
Dark Reading logo in a gray background | Dark Reading

Feedback is important to all of us. It helps us learn, grow, mature, and better adjust to our surroundings. If we learn how to receive feedback well, we will be able to improve, whether it be in our personal life or in our professional career in cybersecurity. On the other hand, if we don't receive feedback well, it can hold us back.

That said, providing feedback is a sensitive and difficult topic that can take a lifetime to master. While I haven't yet mastered this skill, I know a thing or two about the personalities of security professionals. It is in this spirit that I offer six tips for giving positive feedback to security professionals.

Tip 1: Pick your battles: Knowing when to engage is an important skill in life, including when it comes to providing feedback. If you never provide any feedback on anything, nothing will ever change or improve. On the other hand, if you always provide feedback on every little thing, people feel criticized and micromanaged. When is the right time to provide feedback? In general, only in instances when feedback actually makes a difference. By that, I mean when changing something will have a direct impact on the efficiency or effectiveness of the security program — for example, requesting that a specific, noisy alert be tuned to reduce false positives and improve the efficiency of the security team. Or fixing a broken process in order to improve the overall performance of the security team.

Tip 2: Suggest: When providing feedback, it's always more helpful to suggest a practical, tangible solution, rather than expressing displeasure with what is currently happening. You may be absolutely right in your critique, but if it doesn't come with a practical alternative, it's really just complaining. A viable option goes a long way toward getting results.

Tip 3: Never assume: We are all human, and we all have our own subjective biases. That being said, feedback needs to be offered on the basis of facts and objectivity. Think you understand how someone is accomplishing a given task? Verify that your understanding is the truth. Feel like you know someone's motivation for doing something or what that person is after? Better check that feeling out against the facts. Assumptions don't help with providing feedback. They only make the receiver focus on assumptions versus the actual focus of the feedback. This often leads to unnecessary conflict or to taking things personally. Neither helps solve the problem.

Tip 4: Don't jump to conclusions: It's far too easy to connect dots that aren't actually connected. When it comes to providing feedback, we need to make sure that we really understand the facts and reality of the situation we're addressing. Otherwise, we put the value of our feedback at risk. It only takes one inaccuracy for someone who is not interested in or receptive to our feedback to rationalize dismissing it.

Tip 5: If it ain't broke, don't fix it: This colloquial proverb offers some very wise advice for those of us in the security profession. There are some people in our field who seem to want to provide feedback about just about everything. This feedback seems to come whether or not it was asked for, and whether or not it is relevant to the discussion at hand. The problem with this is that sometimes, things actually work as they should. If a process, technology, capability, employee, or anything else is working just as it should, save your breath. Hold back those words and don't provide feedback in those instances. Resources are scarce in security and should be invested in areas where they can have an impact by making a change — not in areas that don't need any fixing.

Tip 6: If you dish it, take it: I've met too many people who provide plenty of feedback but cannot accept any of it. By accepting feedback in the same spirit that it is given, you'll find that not only will you improve personally and professionally but that others will put more value on the feedback that you provide to them.

Related Content:

 

 

Join Dark Reading LIVE for two cybersecurity summits at Interop 2019. Learn from the industry's most knowledgeable IT security experts. Check out the Interop agenda here.

About the Author

Joshua Goldfarb

Field CISO, F5

Josh Goldfarb is currently Field CISO at F5. Previously, Josh served as VP and CTO of Emerging Technologies at FireEye and as Chief Security Officer for nPulse Technologies until its acquisition by FireEye. Prior to joining nPulse, Josh worked as an independent consultant, applying his analytical methodology to help enterprises build and enhance their network traffic analysis, security operations, and incident response capabilities to improve their information security postures. Earlier in his career, Josh served as the Chief of Analysis for the United States Computer Emergency Readiness Team, where he built from the ground up and subsequently ran the network, endpoint, and malware analysis/forensics capabilities for US-CERT. In addition to Josh's blogging and public speaking appearances, he is also a regular contributor to Dark Reading and SecurityWeek.

Keep up with the latest cybersecurity threats, newly discovered vulnerabilities, data breach information, and emerging trends. Delivered daily or weekly right to your email inbox.

You May Also Like


More Insights